Patent Express Logo
Contact us
Toll-free: (877)-794-9511
Ask a question
Ask a question
See Questions and Answers
See Questions and Answers
Discover more services
Discover more services
Search for Patent Questions:
 

Apache license

Posted by Anonymous . updated on 2/26/2009
I would be interested in experienced interpretations of the Apache license at:

  http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0

More specifically the section focused on patents:


.......
3. Grant of Patent License. Subject to the terms and conditions of this License, each Contributor hereby grants to You a perpetual, worldwide, non-exclusive, no-charge, royalty-free, irrevocable (except as stated in this section) patent license to make, have made, use, offer to sell, sell, import, and otherwise transfer the Work, where such license applies only to those patent claims licensable by such Contributor that are necessarily infringed by their Contribution(s) alone or by combination of their Contribution(s) with the Work to which such Contribution(s) was submitted. If You institute patent litigation against any entity (including a cross-claim or counterclaim in a lawsuit) alleging that the Work or a Contribution incorporated within the Work constitutes direct or contributory patent infringement, then any patent licenses granted to You under this License for that Work shall terminate as of the date such litigation is filed.
.......


What I find hard to distinguish from this license is how this may affect someone from selling software that is derived from an Apache project (and covered by this license) but the software includes enhancements that are covered by a patent.  In other words, make an enhancement/addition to  Apache where that enhancement is covered by a patent - can it be sold commercially or is one forgoing the patent rights?
Answers (1)
 
JimIvey
I know this is a month old, but I've been busy....

Being a fan of open source software (OSS) and a patent attorney practicing in computer technology with emphasis on software, I thought I should say a little something....

I think the answer depends and who owns the patent in your question.  Mods (modifications, not apache modules) to apache wouldn't be sold -- I assume the apache license is similar to most OSS licenses in this respect and requires that you give your mods to the apache group and that you don't restrict others in the use or modification of apache, including your modifications.  I may be mistating things, I believe you'd give your mods away freely.

The gist of the clause, as I understand it, is that you agree not to sue anyone for infringement of any of your patents regarding any aspect of apache -- in exchange for using apache.  Of course, nothing in the license stops others for suing apache users for patent infringement.  I don't see that the clause stops you from suing anyone for patent infringement arising out of use of any other software product (explicitly limts itself to "the Work" and "a Contribution.").

For what it's worth, no OSS contributor has ever been sued for patent infringement.  Ever.  A few large, corporate Linux distributors were sued over copyrights, but I think that failed.

Regards.
 
Related Questions
In Patent Process    -  posted on 4/22/2009
I was reading an article about a discovery made by a professor. While reading it, I came up with an application of the discovery that could be very successful. What are the approaches that I can use to get m...   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Patent Process    -  posted on 4/12/2009
This is to clarify a question that I asked earlier. I was reading an article about an invention made by a professor. While reading it, I came up with an application of the invention that could be very succes...   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Patent Process    -  posted on 4/23/2009
re: patenting an application Given that a technology has become protected under patent, and other, law, can an application of that technology be patented by someone other than the owner of the original techn...   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Patent Process    -  posted on 2/1/2008
sir, i am a docter,i have done( bams),and now i want to make a helicopter;with the help of some part of motorbike,so is any law which can stop me to do particular work.and 2nd thing i am not using any one''s...   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Patent Process    -  posted on 4/24/2009
what forms do i need to file a patent   Read MoreAnswer this question
Why Patent Express?
  • Patent Express is the fastest and easiest way for an individual inventor to file a U.S. Patent or Trademark Application.
  • Patent Express fills the gap for those who cannot afford a U.S. patent attorney or agent, but want to have their patent drafted and issued.
  • Patent Express is backed by a 100% money back guarantee.
Save 95% more in register a trademark
Patent Express Services
 

PatentExpress.com is a website of Raj Abhyanker, a professional U.S. Patent Law firm, see: www.rajpatent.com for more. All non-do-it-yourself related services advertised on this site are supervised and managed by a U.S. patent attorney.

© PatentExpress.com All rights reserved. Disclaimer: The information provided in this site is not legal advice, but general information on legal issues commonly encountered. Please note that your access to and use of PatentExpress.com is subject to additional terms and conditions. 07-29-2014