Patent Express Logo
Contact us
Toll-free: (877)-794-9511
Ask a question
Ask a question
See Questions and Answers
See Questions and Answers
Discover more services
Discover more services
Search for Patent Questions:
 

food formula patents

Posted by . updated on 10/26/2004
Last year I met someone at a professional convention representing a foods patent atty out of NYC. This year, I have been accused of ''making it up'' by a woman in a food business (who claims to be legal savy) who says that food formulas or recipies (even if absolutely unique and not found in the market) ''CANNOT be patented in any way''. I know food patents are not done often for obvious reasons, but what about protection of unique and fresh formulas and/or methods? Also, are there any food patent specialists in NJ and what is a baseline figure to patent a unique item (if it can be proven to be so?)
Answers (2)
 
Alan Albin
Your question is not clear. What, exactly, have you been accused of "making...up"? No lawyer will be able to advise you as to whether a particular invention you have in mind is or is not subject to patent protection without actually being retained to review the specific invention. So, you need to retain an intellectual property attorney who specializes in food products. You may benefit more from trade secret protection rather than patent protection with a food product. In order to patent an invention, its formulation must be publicly disclosed in patent office filings. If so, your competitors could "reverse engineer" your product more easily (think Coca-Cola vs. Pepsi). That being said, it is difficult to think of any food recipe which would be original enough, yet non-reverse-engineerable, which would benefit from patent protection. I.e. if your product is a new recipe for brownies, you would obviously be building on the work of others, perhaps with some different combination of ingredients. However, simply putting in a number of different ingredients does not seem original or non-obvious enough to warrant patent protection. Again, you might be better off with a trade-secret methodology for a recipe or similar food product formulation, i.e. like the "secret formula" for Coca-Cola. Or, grandma's "secret recipe" for brownies.
 
 
Walter ...
I agree with Alan, that unless you are developing not a process or receipe, but "creating" a new "food", there is probably nothing eligible for a patent. However, since this is a specialized field, I suggest contacting a qualified patent attorney (I could recommend several I work with or the local bar association referral service can provide you with names) to determine if your concept is subject to a patent or some other formulae protection.
 
Related Questions
In Is it Patentable?    -  posted on 9/14/2007
If someone has something patented, could I make something something similar but different or is this infringement? I came up with an idea but found someone had patented a similar one 10 years ago. It's close...   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Is it Patentable?    -  posted on 4/22/2009
Hi, i would like to know it violates any patent law to use a name that has already been patent but not in the same exact way (different writing and it has word/ patent name /word?   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Is it Patentable?    -  posted on 4/23/2007
a person spots a tree in a field that is growing fruit in the dormant season and patents the tree. Is this legal?   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Is it Patentable?    -  posted on 3/16/2007
I have recently come across new bussiness Idea. It is for an entertainment services company. Can this be patented? Or is it just the bussiness structure that can be patented? This is a franchise I hope to st...   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Is it Patentable?    -  posted on 12/29/2004
My brother has the ''Edison gene'' with ideas abundant. Many are invention ideas that are surely not patentable. A generic patent may or may not work. Is there a history of nonpatentable ideas that were secu...   Read MoreAnswer this question
Previous question: Utility patent costs >>
Next question: Patents >>
Why Patent Express?
  • Patent Express is the fastest and easiest way for an individual inventor to file a U.S. Patent or Trademark Application.
  • Patent Express fills the gap for those who cannot afford a U.S. patent attorney or agent, but want to have their patent drafted and issued.
  • Patent Express is backed by a 100% money back guarantee.
Save 95% more in register a trademark
Patent Express Services
 

PatentExpress.com is a website of Raj Abhyanker, a professional U.S. Patent Law firm, see: www.rajpatent.com for more. All non-do-it-yourself related services advertised on this site are supervised and managed by a U.S. patent attorney.

© PatentExpress.com All rights reserved. Disclaimer: The information provided in this site is not legal advice, but general information on legal issues commonly encountered. Please note that your access to and use of PatentExpress.com is subject to additional terms and conditions. 08-19-2014