Patent Express Logo
Contact us
Toll-free: (877)-794-9511
Ask a question
Ask a question
See Questions and Answers
See Questions and Answers
Discover more services
Discover more services
Search for Patent Questions:
 

Patentability

Posted by Anonymous . updated on 2/26/2009
Say a pill currently available to the public has 10 different chemicals in it. It is not currently patented. If a company were to take those chemicals and put them into a beverage, would it be novel enough to be patentable? Would the pill be prior art that would prevent a patent?
Answers (3)
 
M. Arth...
Likely not.
 
 
JimIvey
My guess is that Mr. Auslander was answering your former question, not the latter.  I'd have to say that I agree with him.

The challenge here is that there's a significant body of patent law specific to chemical inventions and I'm not familiar with that body of law.  For example, what aspect of a claim specifies or doesn't specify whether the chemical components can be in an ionized solution (beverage) or a mixture (pill).  Does it make a difference?  I don't know.  

That's one of the reasons I say that a chemistry-based practice is a specialty all its own within the specialty of a patent practice.

Regards.
 
 
M. Arth...
Clark Boardman never put out of further edition of Chemical Inventions and Chemical Patents which I Co Authored years ago.
 
Related Questions
In Is it Patentable?    -  posted on 9/14/2007
If someone has something patented, could I make something something similar but different or is this infringement? I came up with an idea but found someone had patented a similar one 10 years ago. It's close...   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Is it Patentable?    -  posted on 4/22/2009
Hi, i would like to know it violates any patent law to use a name that has already been patent but not in the same exact way (different writing and it has word/ patent name /word?   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Is it Patentable?    -  posted on 4/23/2007
a person spots a tree in a field that is growing fruit in the dormant season and patents the tree. Is this legal?   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Is it Patentable?    -  posted on 3/16/2007
I have recently come across new bussiness Idea. It is for an entertainment services company. Can this be patented? Or is it just the bussiness structure that can be patented? This is a franchise I hope to st...   Read MoreAnswer this question
In Is it Patentable?    -  posted on 12/29/2004
My brother has the ''Edison gene'' with ideas abundant. Many are invention ideas that are surely not patentable. A generic patent may or may not work. Is there a history of nonpatentable ideas that were secu...   Read MoreAnswer this question
Previous question: Need some hlp please!! >>
Why Patent Express?
  • Patent Express is the fastest and easiest way for an individual inventor to file a U.S. Patent or Trademark Application.
  • Patent Express fills the gap for those who cannot afford a U.S. patent attorney or agent, but want to have their patent drafted and issued.
  • Patent Express is backed by a 100% money back guarantee.
Save 95% more in register a trademark
Patent Express Services
 

PatentExpress.com is a website of Raj Abhyanker, a professional U.S. Patent Law firm, see: www.rajpatent.com for more. All non-do-it-yourself related services advertised on this site are supervised and managed by a U.S. patent attorney.

© PatentExpress.com All rights reserved. Disclaimer: The information provided in this site is not legal advice, but general information on legal issues commonly encountered. Please note that your access to and use of PatentExpress.com is subject to additional terms and conditions. 02-07-2012